Wills, Trusts & Probate
That's All We Do
Complete Guide to Irrevocable Trusts for Portola Hills Residents
Establishing an irrevocable trust in Portola Hills, California can be a powerful part of a thoughtful estate plan. An irrevocable trust changes ownership of selected assets so they are managed and distributed under terms that cannot easily be altered by the person who transferred them. Many residents turn to this approach to protect family wealth, support long-term care planning, and create clear pathways for inheritance. At LA Estate Plans we assist clients with designing irrevocable trusts that reflect their goals, clarify responsibilities, and address the particular rules that apply in Orange County. Our approach focuses on clear explanations and practical steps so clients feel confident about their choices.
Irrevocable trusts are often used when permanence and legal protection of assets are priorities. Because assets placed into an irrevocable trust are generally removed from the grantor’s direct ownership, the arrangement can influence tax position, eligibility for certain government benefits, and protection from some creditor claims. Portola Hills residents who are considering this option typically have specific reasons such as long-term care planning or legacy preservation. We help you weigh the tradeoffs, identify the right assets to transfer, and structure the trust terms to meet family needs while complying with California law. To discuss whether an irrevocable trust fits your plan, contact LA Estate Plans at 310-634-1006.
Why Irrevocable Trusts Matter in Estate Planning
Irrevocable trusts matter for people who want added protection and predictability in how assets are preserved and distributed. Because the trust normally cannot be revoked by the person who funded it, assets are removed from the grantor’s estate in ways that can reduce exposure to certain taxes and may assist with eligibility for government programs. Irrevocable trusts also create a durable framework for providing ongoing support to family members, protecting assets from some claims, and minimizing potential family disputes. For many Portola Hills residents these features make an irrevocable trust an attractive complement to wills and revocable trusts.
About LA Estate Plans and Our Trust Planning Services
LA Estate Plans focuses on wills, trusts, and probate services for clients throughout Orange County, including Portola Hills. Our practice emphasizes client communication, careful document preparation, and local knowledge of California law. When creating an irrevocable trust we work to draft clear provisions, advise on funding procedures, and support the selection of a trustee who can carry out the trust’s terms. We aim to make complex legal choices easier to understand and manage. If you would like a detailed conversation about trust options tailored to your situation, our team is available by phone at 310-634-1006 to schedule a consultation.
Understanding Irrevocable Trusts and How They Work
An irrevocable trust is a legal arrangement through which the person creating the trust transfers ownership of specified assets into a separate legal entity governed by a trust agreement. Once assets are placed into the trust, the grantor typically gives up direct control over them, and a trustee manages the property according to the instructions in the trust document. Irrevocable trusts are commonly used for asset protection, Medicaid planning, and to manage distributions to beneficiaries who may need oversight. Because the trust terms are generally fixed, it is important to consider long-term goals and family dynamics before finalizing the arrangement.
Setting up an irrevocable trust requires a number of careful steps, including drafting a clear trust agreement, identifying which assets will be transferred, and completing the legal steps to retitle property and accounts into the trust’s name. The trustee will have duties to manage and distribute trust assets according to the document, and the grantor should understand the tax and legal consequences of removing assets from personal ownership. In California there are specific rules and formalities that must be followed to ensure the trust accomplishes the intended purposes, and thoughtful planning helps avoid unintended results.
Definition: What an Irrevocable Trust Is and What It Does
An irrevocable trust is a trust arrangement where, once assets are transferred, the trust terms are generally fixed and not subject to unilateral change by the grantor. The trustee administers those assets for the benefit of named beneficiaries under the trust’s provisions. This structure can offer legal protections and a high degree of predictability for how property will be handled over time. Because the grantor typically cannot reclaim assets or alter the trust without agreement from beneficiaries or court approval, the decision to create an irrevocable trust should be informed by the grantor’s long-term objectives and family circumstances.
Key Components and the Process for Establishing an Irrevocable Trust
Establishing an irrevocable trust involves several core elements: a clear trust agreement that specifies distribution rules, identification and transfer of trust assets, and appointment of a trustee who will manage the trust. The process also includes carefully documenting transfers, retitling accounts, and preparing any ancillary paperwork required by financial institutions or governmental authorities. Close attention to these details ensures the trust is funded effectively and operates in line with the grantor’s intentions. Proper planning also anticipates future scenarios, such as changes in family circumstances and tax implications.
Essential Terms You Should Know About Irrevocable Trusts
Becoming familiar with basic trust vocabulary helps clarify roles and responsibilities. Key terms include grantor, trustee, beneficiary, and trust corpus, and understanding these definitions will make it easier to follow the trust creation process and to plan transfers of assets. Knowing how each role interacts with others and what legal duties accompany particular positions reduces confusion down the road. This foundation enables better decision making when selecting trustees, naming beneficiaries, and describing distribution conditions in the trust document.
Grantor (Trust Creator)
The grantor is the individual who creates and funds the irrevocable trust by transferring assets into the trust structure. After funding the trust, the grantor generally no longer controls those assets directly, as ownership rests with the trust. The grantor’s intent is recorded in the trust document, which details how assets are to be managed and distributed. Understanding the grantor’s goals and the long-term implications of removing assets from personal ownership is an important part of planning and ensures the trust aligns with family needs and overall estate planning objectives.
Beneficiary (Person or Entity Receiving Benefits)
A beneficiary is an individual or organization designated to receive income, principal, or other benefits from the trust according to the terms the grantor sets out. The trust document determines how and when beneficiaries receive distributions and may include conditions or schedules. Beneficiaries may be family members, charities, or other entities, and their needs and circumstances often drive important drafting decisions. Clarity around beneficiary designations prevents confusion and helps ensure that distributions are carried out in a way that reflects the grantor’s intentions.
Trustee (Trust Manager and Fiduciary)
The trustee is the person or institution charged with managing the trust assets and carrying out the trust terms for the benefit of the beneficiaries. Trustees must follow the trust document and applicable law while making decisions about investments, distributions, and recordkeeping. Choosing the right trustee involves evaluating reliability, availability, and capacity to handle ongoing administrative duties. Trustees also have legal responsibilities to act in the beneficiaries’ interests and to maintain transparent records of trust activities and decisions.
Trust Corpus (Assets Held in Trust)
The trust corpus refers to the assets and property that have been transferred into the irrevocable trust and are managed under its terms. These assets might include real estate, investment accounts, insurance policies, or business interests. Properly funding the trust requires retitling assets and completing paperwork so that ownership is clearly in the name of the trust. The composition of the corpus affects how the trust can be administered and what tax or reporting obligations apply. Thoughtful asset selection and transfer help the trust fulfill its intended purpose.
Comparing Irrevocable Trusts with Other Estate Planning Tools
When planning an estate, it is useful to compare irrevocable trusts with revocable trusts, wills, and powers of attorney. Revocable trusts allow the creator to retain control and make changes, while irrevocable trusts typically restrict changes in exchange for added protection. Wills provide direction at death but generally must go through probate, whereas properly funded trusts can avoid probate and provide continuity. Powers of attorney govern decisions during incapacity but do not transfer ownership of assets. Evaluating these options together helps identify the mix that best fits a family’s objectives and circumstances in Portola Hills.
When a Simpler Estate Plan May Be Appropriate:
Simple Asset Distribution Needs
If estate goals are limited to straightforward distribution of modest assets, a basic will or a revocable trust may be sufficient. These tools provide flexibility to change terms as circumstances evolve and are easier to amend when life events occur such as marriage, birth, or changes in asset ownership. For individuals whose priority is simplicity and the ability to adapt their plan over time, less restrictive arrangements allow continued control over property and reduce the legal formalities associated with transferring assets into an irrevocable structure.
Minimal Asset Protection Requirements
When there is little exposure to creditor claims, litigation risks, or government benefit planning concerns, the need for an irrevocable trust may be limited. In those circumstances, maintaining ownership flexibility through a revocable trust or will can be preferable, allowing easier management and fewer restrictions. People in this position often value the ability to change beneficiaries or adjust terms in response to changing family dynamics and financial conditions without the permanence that an irrevocable trust imposes.
When a Comprehensive Irrevocable Trust Approach Is Advisable:
Protecting Assets from Creditors and Lawsuits
For individuals facing elevated exposure to legal claims or professional liability, an irrevocable trust can provide stronger protection than revocable arrangements because transferred assets are typically no longer part of the grantor’s personal estate. This separation helps shield assets from certain creditor actions and can preserve resources for family members. Proper timing and careful structuring are essential to obtain these protections, and planning should consider state laws and the specific nature of potential risks so the trust delivers the intended safeguards.
Medicaid and Government Benefit Planning
Irrevocable trusts are commonly used as part of long-term care and Medicaid planning because they can remove assets from a person’s countable estate for eligibility purposes. When structured and funded properly, these trusts may help individuals qualify for government support while preserving some assets for heirs. Timing, document language, and transfer rules must be handled carefully to comply with applicable regulations. Thoughtful planning helps balance the need for benefit eligibility with the goal of protecting family assets for future generations.
Advantages of a Comprehensive Irrevocable Trust Strategy
A comprehensive approach to an irrevocable trust provides multiple advantages including enhanced legal protection for transferred assets, clearer administration instructions for trustees, and the ability to tailor distributions to beneficiaries’ needs. When a trust is well drafted, it reduces the potential for disputes, supports continuity of management, and allows the grantor to set conditions for distributions that reflect long-term family goals. This structure often provides greater predictability and peace of mind compared with relying solely on wills or revocable trusts.
In addition to asset protection, a carefully structured irrevocable trust can assist with tax planning and streamline post-death administration. Because assets held in certain trust formats may be excluded from an individual’s taxable estate, there can be opportunities to manage estate tax exposure. The detailed rules in the trust also help trustees carry out distributions consistently, which can be especially valuable for families that need oversight for minor or vulnerable beneficiaries. For Portola Hills residents, these benefits help preserve family wealth and provide a clear legacy plan.
Enhanced Protection Against Creditors
When assets are properly placed in an irrevocable trust, they are generally separated from the grantor’s personal estate and may be harder for creditors to reach. This sheltering effect is one reason people choose irrevocable trusts for wealth preservation. The degree of protection depends on timing, local law, and the particular terms of the trust, so it is important to structure the arrangement carefully. With thoughtful planning, a trust can be designed to minimize exposure to claims while still providing for family members according to the grantor’s intentions.
Tax Efficiency and Easier Estate Administration
Irrevocable trusts can offer opportunities to reduce estate tax exposure by removing certain assets from the taxable estate, depending on applicable law and how transfers are structured. They also allow administration to proceed under the trust terms rather than through probate, which can simplify distribution and preserve privacy for the family. Clear documentation and proper funding of the trust make administration smoother for trustees and beneficiaries, reducing the time and uncertainty often associated with settling an estate.
Practice Areas
Top Searched Keywords
- Irrevocable trust Portola Hills
- Irrevocable trust attorney Orange County
- Medicaid planning Portola Hills
- trust administration California
- asset protection trust Orange County
- funding an irrevocable trust
- trustee duties California
- trust corpus retitling
- estate planning Portola Hills
Practical Tips for Establishing an Irrevocable Trust
Understand the Long-Term Commitment
Creating an irrevocable trust is a long-term decision because assets transferred into the trust are typically not returned to the grantor’s personal ownership. Before funding a trust, take time to consider family goals, potential future needs, and how distributions will be handled. Think through scenarios such as changes in family composition, future care needs, and tax consequences. Clear intent and careful documentation at the outset reduce the likelihood of unintended outcomes and help ensure the trust remains aligned with the grantor’s priorities for years to come.
Choose a Trustee Wisely
Review Your Estate Plan Regularly
Even though an irrevocable trust imposes permanence on the assets placed into it, the remainder of an estate plan should be reviewed periodically to reflect life changes such as births, deaths, marriages, or significant changes in assets. Regular reviews allow adjustments to related estate planning documents and ensure that beneficiary designations outside the trust remain consistent with overall goals. Checking tax law developments and financial account structures is also important to ensure the trust continues to operate as intended and that funding remains complete and accurate.
Reasons to Consider an Irrevocable Trust in Portola Hills
People often choose irrevocable trusts when the priority is to protect assets, plan for long-term care costs, or provide structured distributions to family members. Removing assets from personal ownership can assist with qualifying for certain government benefits and can reduce estate tax exposure in appropriate situations. Irrevocable trusts also help preserve family wealth for future generations and reduce the potential for disputes by setting clear directions for trustees and beneficiaries. For many families in Portola Hills, these considerations make an irrevocable trust a compelling option.
Other motivating factors include managing assets for beneficiaries who may not be ready to handle large distributions, protecting inherited assets from claims, or setting aside resources for long term medical or educational needs. Because trust terms are typically binding, they can enforce prudent distribution schedules and conditions that reflect the grantor’s values. Thoughtful planning around trustee selection, trust provisions, and funding strategies helps ensure the trust serves the intended purpose while remaining consistent with California legal requirements.
Common Situations Where an Irrevocable Trust Is Useful
An irrevocable trust is often used when the goals include long-term asset protection, Medicaid eligibility planning, or provision for beneficiaries who need oversight. It is also appropriate where property should be preserved for future generations or placed beyond the reach of potential creditors. Business owners, individuals with significant assets, or those facing increased liability risks may find an irrevocable trust helps align asset protection with estate planning goals. Evaluating personal circumstances, timing of transfers, and trust terms ensures the arrangement supports the intended outcomes.
Protection from Legal Claims and Creditors
Individuals exposed to potential liability, professional risk, or significant creditor exposure may use an irrevocable trust to protect certain assets. By transferring ownership to the trust, those assets are generally separated from the grantor’s personal estate, which may reduce vulnerability to claims. Proper timing and compliance with legal requirements are essential to obtain this protection and avoid unintended consequences. A well-structured trust can offer a controlled way to preserve wealth while still providing for family distribution according to the grantor’s wishes.
Medicaid and Long-Term Care Planning
Irrevocable trusts are frequently part of strategies for long-term care planning because they can remove countable assets for Medicaid eligibility when done properly. These arrangements must be executed with careful attention to timing, look-back rules, and state-specific regulations to be effective. The goal is to balance access to needed benefits with the preservation of family resources. Because the rules can be complex, planning ahead and documenting transfers thoroughly are key steps to achieving the desired result while remaining compliant with California law.
Providing for Minor or Vulnerable Beneficiaries
When beneficiaries are minors, have limited financial capacity, or require protection from creditors, an irrevocable trust can ensure that assets are managed and distributed responsibly. The trust document can include tailored distribution rules, age-based release provisions, or terms that require trustee oversight before funds are disbursed. This structure helps preserve resources for the beneficiary’s long-term needs and protects assets from mismanagement. Thoughtful drafting of distribution standards and trustee authorities supports responsible stewardship over time.
We Are Here to Help Portola Hills Residents with Trust Planning
Why Choose LA Estate Plans for Your Irrevocable Trust Needs
LA Estate Plans brings focused experience in wills, trusts, and probate matters for clients across Orange County. We prioritize clear communication and practical guidance tailored to Portola Hills residents. Our approach is to listen carefully to family goals, explain legal tradeoffs in plain language, and draft documents that reflect your intentions. We place emphasis on ensuring the trust is properly funded and structured to meet long-term objectives while complying with California law.
Throughout the trust process we aim to be responsive and transparent about timing, costs, and the steps needed to complete the arrangement. We walk clients through retitling assets, coordinating with financial institutions, and preparing any ancillary documents that support the trust’s function. Regular updates and clear next steps help reduce uncertainty and make the process manageable for families handling important long-term planning matters.
Our practice focuses on providing practical solutions that help preserve family assets and clarify post-death administration. We work with grantors and trustees to draft durable instruments and to prepare clear administrative directions. By emphasizing communication and personalized service, we help families implement trusts that align with their values and financial goals. To begin reviewing your options for an irrevocable trust, reach out to LA Estate Plans at 310-634-1006.
Schedule Your Irrevocable Trust Consultation Today
How We Handle Irrevocable Trust Matters
Our process begins with a thorough consultation to understand your goals and the resources you wish to protect. We then recommend a tailored strategy, prepare the trust document, and assist with the funding steps needed to place assets into the trust. After execution we support trustees with administrative guidance and help maintain accurate records. Our aim is to make each phase clear and manageable so families can focus on their priorities while the trust is put into operation according to California law.
Initial Consultation and Assessment
During the initial consultation we discuss your estate planning goals, family situation, and the assets you intend to protect. We assess whether an irrevocable trust is the right tool and outline alternative approaches if appropriate. This conversation includes a review of timing considerations, potential tax and benefit implications, and the steps required to fund the trust. The goal is to create a clear plan that matches your priorities before drafting formal documents.
Discuss Goals and Review Assets
We take time to understand your short and long-term objectives, including how you would like assets distributed and what protections you want in place. Reviewing assets such as real estate, investment accounts, and business interests helps determine which items are suitable for transfer into a trust. Clear documentation of ownership and values is important to ensure transfers are completed properly and the trust is funded as intended.
Gather Financial and Family Information
Collecting detailed financial information and understanding family relationships helps us tailor trust terms to your needs. We ask about beneficiaries, potential contingencies, and any special circumstances that could affect distribution priorities. This step also identifies whether additional planning tools are necessary to complement the trust and ensures the proposed structure reflects your broader estate plan.
Drafting and Finalizing Trust Documents
After the planning stage we prepare a draft trust agreement that sets out who will benefit, trustee powers, distribution conditions, and administrative rules. The draft is reviewed with you so adjustments can be made to reflect your wishes precisely. Once finalized, the documents are signed and witnessed as required by state law to ensure proper execution. Clear drafting helps trustees administer the trust smoothly and reduces the potential for later disputes.
Drafting the Trust Agreement
Drafting involves translating your goals into precise language that governs trustee duties, beneficiary rights, and distribution mechanics. We include provisions for trustee succession, accounting requirements, and contingencies for changing circumstances. The goal is to create a durable document that provides clear guidance to trustees and protects the interests of beneficiaries while respecting applicable California rules.
Reviewing and Revising Trust Terms
We review the draft trust with you, explain key provisions, and revise language as needed to reflect preferences and family circumstances. This collaborative review ensures the document captures your objectives and anticipates likely scenarios. Making thoughtful revisions at this stage is important because changes to an irrevocable trust after execution are often limited and may require beneficiary consent or court involvement.
Transferring Assets and Ongoing Administration
Once the trust agreement is executed, the next critical task is funding the trust by retitling property and updating account ownership where appropriate. Proper funding ensures the assets intended to be protected are actually held by the trust. Following funding, trustees must manage assets, keep accurate records, and make distributions according to the trust terms. We provide guidance on these administrative steps and assist trustees in meeting their obligations over the life of the trust.
Transferring Property and Accounts into the Trust
Funding the trust typically requires changing titles, beneficiary designations, or account registrations to reflect trust ownership. Real estate requires recorded deeds, and financial accounts may need new registration or institutional forms. Attention to details such as tax reporting and transfer documentation helps avoid gaps in funding and ensures assets receive the protections intended under the trust terms. Proper coordination with institutions is an essential part of completing the trust setup.
Supporting Trustees with Ongoing Duties and Recordkeeping
Trustees have ongoing responsibilities including investment oversight, tax reporting, and distribution administration in accordance with the trust terms. We provide trustees with guidance on recordkeeping, required notices, and how to handle routine decisions that arise during trust administration. Clear procedures and documentation help trustees fulfill their duties and reduce the risk of disputes or misunderstandings with beneficiaries over time.
The Proof is in Our Performance
Frequently Asked Questions About Irrevocable Trusts in Portola Hills
How does an irrevocable trust differ from a revocable trust?
A revocable trust allows the person who created it to retain control and make changes while they are alive, including revoking the trust if desired. A revocable trust is often used for flexibility and to avoid probate, but it does not offer the same level of asset separation as an irrevocable trust. In contrast, an irrevocable trust typically prevents the grantor from reclaiming assets or unilaterally changing the terms, which can provide stronger protection in certain situations. Choosing between these options depends on priorities such as control, protection, tax considerations, and eligibility for government programs. For many Portola Hills residents, discussing family goals and potential risks clarifies which trust form best matches their needs.
Can an irrevocable trust be modified after it is created?
An irrevocable trust is generally designed to be permanent, and modifications are limited compared with revocable arrangements. In certain circumstances changes can be made with the consent of all beneficiaries, by using trust provisions that allow limited modification, or through court petitions that address unforeseen situations. Such modifications are typically more complex and may require formal legal procedures. Because changes are often difficult, careful planning at the outset is important. Reviewing family goals and anticipating likely scenarios before funding the trust helps avoid the need for later modifications and ensures the trust functions as intended.
What are the tax implications of an irrevocable trust?
Assets placed into an irrevocable trust are frequently removed from the grantor’s personal taxable estate, which can reduce estate tax exposure in appropriate cases. The trust itself may have its own tax reporting obligations, and income produced by trust assets can be taxed at trust tax rates unless alternative provisions apply. The specific tax impact depends on the type of trust and how it is funded. Because tax rules are nuanced and can change, it is advisable to coordinate trust planning with a tax professional. This coordination helps ensure transfers and trust provisions achieve the intended tax results while complying with California and federal tax laws.
Who can act as the trustee for an irrevocable trust?
A trustee can be an individual such as a trusted family member or friend, or an institution such as a bank or trust company. The key considerations when choosing a trustee include reliability, willingness to serve, administrative ability, and impartiality when making decisions for multiple beneficiaries. Trustee selection should reflect the complexity of the trust and the needs of the beneficiaries. Many people select a combination approach by naming an individual trustee with an institutional co-trustee or successor to provide continuity. Careful selection and clear instructions in the trust document help trustees perform their duties effectively and reduce potential conflicts.
Which assets are suitable for transfer into an irrevocable trust?
Common assets placed into irrevocable trusts include real estate, investment accounts, closely held business interests, and certain life insurance policies. The suitability of an asset depends on factors such as liquidity, transferability, tax consequences, and whether the asset’s transfer accomplishes the intended protective or eligibility goals. Some assets may require additional documentation or formal retitling to transfer ownership to the trust. Properly funding the trust is essential; simply creating the trust document without completing transfers will not achieve the intended protections. Coordination with financial institutions and careful attention to title and beneficiary designations are necessary steps to ensure assets become part of the trust corpus.
Can an irrevocable trust shield assets from creditors and lawsuits?
An irrevocable trust can provide a level of separation that helps protect assets from certain creditors and lawsuits, particularly when transfers are properly timed and structured under applicable law. The degree of protection depends on the type of trust, the timing of transfers relative to potential claims, and applicable state rules. Proper planning can help minimize vulnerabilities and preserve assets for beneficiaries. It is important to avoid transfers intended to defraud creditors, as laws prevent improper use of trusts. A careful and well-documented approach helps ensure the protection is legitimate and consistent with California legal requirements.
How can an irrevocable trust assist with Medicaid and long-term care planning?
Irrevocable trusts are often used in long-term care planning because they can remove assets from an individual’s countable estate for government benefit eligibility when established in compliance with timing and look-back rules. When structured correctly, these trusts may help a person qualify for Medicaid while preserving some resources for heirs. The trust language and funding schedule must align with regulatory requirements. Because Medicaid rules and look-back periods can be complex, early planning and precise documentation are important to achieve the desired benefit eligibility. Consulting with legal and financial advisors helps ensure the trust supports both care needs and family goals.
What responsibilities does a trustee have in an irrevocable trust?
A trustee is responsible for managing trust assets according to the trust document, making distributions to beneficiaries as directed, keeping accurate records, handling tax filings, and acting in the best interests of the beneficiaries. Trustees must follow the legal standards that apply in California, maintain transparency about decisions, and address requests from beneficiaries in line with the trust terms. Trustees often consult with advisors for investment, tax, and administrative matters, and they may rely on professional support when the trust contains complex assets. Clear guidance in the trust document and accessible recordkeeping help trustees meet these responsibilities effectively.
How are trust assets handled after the grantor passes away?
After the grantor passes away, trust assets are administered according to the directions in the trust document. The trustee gathers and values assets, pays any debts and taxes as required, and distributes the remaining property to beneficiaries under the schedule and conditions specified in the trust. Because the trust typically operates outside probate, administration can proceed with greater privacy and potentially less delay. The trustee’s duties include providing notices, maintaining accounting records, and resolving any claims or disputes that arise. Clear trust provisions and complete funding before death reduce uncertainty and help the trustee carry out the grantor’s intentions efficiently.
How do I begin creating an irrevocable trust in Portola Hills?
To begin creating an irrevocable trust in Portola Hills, start with an initial consultation to discuss your goals, family situation, and assets you wish to protect. Gather documentation for property titles, account statements, and any existing estate planning documents so the trust can be tailored to your circumstances. This information helps determine whether an irrevocable trust is appropriate and which assets should be transferred. Once goals are clarified, we draft the trust agreement, review the terms with you, and coordinate the steps needed to fund the trust, such as retitling property and updating account registrations. Careful execution and follow-through ensure the trust fulfills its intended purpose under California law.